Hi All,
I appreciate and respect your views and agree with them, up to a point. And I very much thank your for showing your fish and sharing your experiences, which I value highly.
Yes, I would rather have a large school of Hemiodus in a very large tank. However, for me, that is not possible for several reasons:
Regarding the Hemiodus-
1) I have only seen these fish for sale twice in my life, once at a "natural" aquarium in Cali, Colombia, and the next time was when I bought these fish (x4) at a store in New Jersey. Never again. Increasing the size of the school seems i possible, both because of where to get from, and because the size of the tank; 2) Under my care, they have grown from ~ 5cm to ~ 14 cm in close to 3 years, and have actually become calmer during that time; 3) when I bought them, they had injuries in their "noses", indicative of bumping into walls at the store tanks; the last time I saw any "nose" damage on my fish was at least 2.5 years ago, a few months after I got them. They are now larger, healthier, and calmer, they don't scatter around when I approach, and instead, come forward inquisitively to receive the food I offer or the taps on the glass they have learned to recognize as rewards; 4) If I were seeing any evidence of the fish not doing well, I would conclude that indeed they should not be kept in the 125gal tank I have. However, I don't see any evidence of that being the case. 5) Unfortunately, a tank larger than 6 feet (180cm) is just not possible at this time, unless it is built in place, and frankly, there are other priorities ahead of that.
Regarding the Semaprochilodus (I believe this is what you refer to as 'night tetra') -
This fish is currently 8-9 inches (20-23 cm), and also came to me as a baby (~6.5cm, photos attached). This fish eats from my hand daily and acts as a well-trained puppy. Never does it crash around, becomes startled or anything like that.
Yes, I do know both Hemiodus and Semaprochilodus are schooling fish. In fact, Semaprochilodus are migratory too, which is something even the largest of aquaria cannot offer. I also know that Semaprochilodus can grow to a foot in length (30cm), as I have seen them as a food fish in Colombia, but I also know that it is not he bulk of them who reach that size, and that it takes a number of years to reach that size (about a decade to a foot long fish). But I don't see anything wrong about having them in a tank, which although not as big as it could be, it is not too small or cruel, so long as they look happy, act happy, look healthy, and have the signs of health to go with it. One day, hopefully soon, I will have a larger tank, but it does not seem to me their current situation is cruel or harmful to them, although it is certain that I could not have more fish in there.
This is very different from the often seen large Astronotus in a 40gal tank, or red tail catfish in a 55, or the adult goldfish in a much too small aquarium.
Again, with many thanks and respectful camaraderie.
Francisco